David Cook -- what can I say? Here he brought his own arrangement instead of using someone else's (which he's been criticised for), and um. He still rocks. QED.
Ramiele -- fab voice, poor performance.
Jason -- I thought he was great. I'm not sure if it's because he sang well or because he's so darn cute. I am guessing this is not a good sign. :-P
Carly -- Carly is HARDCORE. I kind of agree with Simon about the clothes, though.
David A -- He is completely and unquestionably phenomenal. But I still think he needs "performing on-stage" pointers.
Kristy Lee -- Okay, that? Voice-wise? Was okay. But it was completely soulless. And Jesus, she's so irritating whenever she's not singing.
Syesha -- Meh. I liked it, didn't love it -- fully agreed with Simon. You don't touch the Whitney version of that song without being compared to Whitney. You simply don't.
Michael -- He's just getting better and better every week. :D
Also, Dolly Parton scares me. o.o